Youth Review Forum Countdown: Chat with Melissa Keil and Christine Bongers

It’s been almost a week since the CBCA winners announcement, and this year Claire Zorn’s ‘The Protected’ took away the coveted title of CBCA Older Reader Book of the Year. A win well deserved; the title was well-received by the students I have the pleasure of working with.

But although we’re heading towards the end of Book Week activities, there is one event a horde of year 9 students across several schools are holding their breath in anticipation for: YOUTH REVIEW FORUM!

What is Youth Review Forum, you ask? Well, each year, groups of avid year 9 readers from several schools across Sydney take part in an initiative designed to give students a voice regarding the six Older Reader titles short listed by the Children’s Book Council of Australia. The Youth Review Forum fosters discussion and debate about what has been deemed the crème de la crème of Australian Young Adult fiction. To read more about the Youth Review Forum go here.

This year’s Short List offered the following titles:

With the date for the Youth Review Forum this upcoming Monday, most of my eager year 9 readers have finished all six titles. Their opinions on each of the texts are interesting to say the least, and I’ll unpack their thoughts on the Short List in a blog post to come at a later date. All I’ll say at this point is that, although the group enjoyed ‘The Protected’, it has named The Incredible Adventures of Cinnamon Girl and The Intruder as their stand-out favourites. I contacted Melissa Keil and Christine Bongers to line up a twitter chat with my students and the talented writers were happy to oblige.

Click on the images below, to read the storified chats. And keep your eye out for @tlkat’s tweets on Monday morning, August 31, where I’ll be madly tweeting the varied views and heated opinions of young adult readers as they discuss the CBCA Older Reader titles at the Youth Review Forum #yrforum

Wide Reading in the Geography Curriculum

Global Inequalities Book Critique Display

Part of my role as a teacher-librarian is to collaborate with teachers in the development of literature-based reading programs. Usually, this occurs within the English curriculum so when the opportunity arose to do so in the context of the Geography classroom, I jumped at the chance for cross-curricular literature integration.

It all started last year when an innovative Geography teacher on staff approached me a week before the winter holidays, asking if I could put together a book box of fiction titles for her year 8 Geography class. She was after texts that in one way or another touched on the topic of Global Inequalities, a year 8 unit under the syllabus focus area of Global Change. Within this unit, students look at extremes of poverty and wealth, variations in access to essential aspects of life such as education, food, shelter and health care, and different life opportunities and quality of life throughout the world. She wanted to widen her students’ exposure to the topics they’d learned about in Geography and saw fiction as one way of doing this. The aim was for the girls to read their fiction text over the school holidays and be ready to tell the class about it at the start of the following term.

The Geography Wide Reading initiative was so successful that this year all three year 8 Geography classes wanted to take part. In collaboration with Geography staff, we formalised the structure of the activity and incorporated a written book critique to be displayed in the Learning Resources Centre, which functioned as both a showcase of student learning and a book promotion tool.

Here’s how we did it:

1. Compiled a list of book titles relating to the themes / ideas related to the Global Inequalities unit.

2. Used a ‘Speed Dating’ approach for book selection:

• Provided students only a photocopy of the first page of each book to base their initial selection on (so they didn’t judge the book by its cover!).
• If students liked their ‘date’ based on these first few minutes of interaction, they were given the book to continue the ‘conversation, which now included reading a few more pages, examining the cover and reading the blurb on the back of the book.
• Asked students to give their ‘date’ a fair chance by reading pages equaling their age and a page, so for year 8 girls this meant 13-15 pages.
• Gave students three days after their initial choice to change their minds and borrow another title from the selected list.

3. Allowed students a two week timeframe to read their chosen book, including time in class.

Book Critique Template

4. Provided students with a Book Critique template to rate aspects of the book and comment on their reading experience in the context of their learning in Geography.

5. Asked the students to use the Book Critique display in the Learning Resources Centre to choose a second book to read over the holidays.

Student Critiques on Display

Teacher and student feedback voted the project a successful and enjoyable experience, allowing students to examine concepts studied in Geography through a literary lens.

Can’t wait to do it again next year!

Have any of you had experience with Wide Reading initiatives in subjects other than English? I’d love to hear about them.